Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor) menu

13 dishes across 5 sections Pizza restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor) photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor) photo menu 1 P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor) photo menu 2

Drinks 4 dishes

  • Gatorade US$4.99

  • Drinks US$1.99

  • Tea US$4.99

    Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.

  • Water US$2.99

Sandwiches & Subs 7 dishes

  • Sausage Sub US$11.95

    Italian sausages, mozzarella cheese topped with our marinara sauce.

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub US$11.95

    Grilled chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese topped with ranch dressing.

  • Vegetable Sub US$11.95

    Veggie sub includes lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & cheese topped with our house Italian dressing.

  • Chicken Parm Sandwich US$8.95

    Chicken Patty, mozzarella topped with marinara sauce on a toasted Kaiser roll.

  • Chicken Sandwich US$7.95

    Honey butter, pickles & chicken patty on a Kaiser roll

  • Meatball Sub US$11.95

    Meatballs, mozzarella cheese topped with our Marinara Sauce.

  • Italian Sub US$11.95

    Ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, lettuce & tomatoes topped with our house Italian dressing.

Strombolis & Calzones 8 dishes

  • Stromboli US$13.95

    Mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and fresh tomatoes.

  • Pepperoni Roll US$10.95

    Mozzarella and Pepperoni, A Local Favorite!!!

  • Sausage Roll US$10.95

    Pizza dough rolled with sausage & mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce.

  • Bread Sticks/Cheez US$9.95

  • Ricotta Calzone US$12.95

    Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese.

  • Bread Sticks US$7.95

  • Garlic Knots US$9.95

  • Calzone US$11.95

    Mozzarella, green peppers, onions.

Specialty Items 8 dishes

  • Stromboli US$14.95

    Mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and fresh tomatoes.

  • Bread Sticks US$7.95

  • Pepperoni Roll US$12.95

    Mozzarella and Pepperoni, A Local Favorite!!!

  • Bread Sticks/Cheez US$9.95

  • Calzone US$14.95

    Mozzarella, green peppers, onions.

  • Garlic Knots US$9.95

  • Sausage Roll US$12.95

    Pizza dough rolled with sausage & mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce.

  • Ricotta Calzone US$14.95

    Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese.

Salads 4 dishes

  • Party Salad US$38.95

    Lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella, black olives, mild pepper rings & pepperoni.

  • Antipasto Salad US$11.95

    same as Large Tossed Salad but also includes a generous amount of Ham & Salami.

  • Toss Salad US$10.95

    lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella, black olives, mild pepper rings, and pepperoni.

  • Party Antipasto Salad US$50.95

    Lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella, black olives, mild pepper rings, pepperoni, salami & ham.

Desserts 2 dishes

  • Cannoli US$4.25

    Made with our homemade ricotta cheese filling and topped with powdered sugar and chocolate chips! each.

  • Chocolate Cannoli US$5.94

    Comes with a chocolate shell.

Wings 1 dishes

  • Wings US$8.95

Appetizers 9 dishes

  • Chicken Tenders US$12.95

  • Fries US$3.99

    Our delicious french fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. seasoned to perfection

  • Jalapeño Poppers US$5.99

    Fried jalapeno mixed with cream cheese.

  • Breaded Mushrooms US$7.25

  • Garlic Bread US$5.95

    Served with marinara sauce.

  • Mozzarella Sticks US$8.45

    5 sticks, plus marinara sauce on the side.

  • Garlic Bread/Cheese US$7.25

    Served with marinara sauce.

  • Onion Rings US$5.99

  • Jojo Fries US$5.99

    potato wedges.

Deluxe Pizzas 6 dishes

  • Small Meat Deluxe US$24.95

  • Sheet Meat Deluxe US$67.95

  • Small Deluxe US$22.95

    Pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onion, mushroom.

  • Small Veggie Deluxe US$22.95

  • Sheet Veggie Deluxe US$65.95

  • Sheet Deluxe US$65.95

Pizzas 8 dishes

  • Small Gluten Pizza US$15.95

  • Super Size Pizza US$18.95

  • Large Pizza Sicilian US$20.95

  • Small Sicilian Pizza US$15.95

  • Sheet Pizza US$30.95

  • Small Pizza US$14.95

  • Large Pizza US$16.95

  • Slice US$2.39

Pasta 10 dishes

  • Eggplant Parmesan Dinner US$18.95

    Includes salad and bread

  • Ravioli Dinner US$17.75

    Includes salad and bread

  • Spaghetti Dinner US$17.95

    Includes salad and bread

  • Cavatelli Dinner US$17.95

    Includes salad and bread

  • Side Ravioli US$14.95

  • Side Cavatelli US$14.95

  • Side Spaghetti US$14.95

  • Side Lasagna US$15.95

  • Lasagna Dinner US$18.95

    Includes salad and bread

  • Side Eggplant Parmesan US$15.95

Alcoholic Beverages 9 dishes

  • Coors Light US$3.60

    Coors light: available in single or 6-pack options.

  • Corona US$3.60

    Corona beer, available in single or 6-pack.

  • Corona Light US$3.60

    Corona light. options include single or 6-pack.

  • White Wine US$9.99

    4 pack

  • Budweiser US$3.00

    Budweiser beer, available as a single or in a 6-pack.

  • Bud Light US$3.00

    Bud light available in single or 6-pack.

  • Miller Lite US$3.00

    Miller lite available in single or 6-pack options.

  • Heineken US$3.60

    Heineken: available in single or 6-pack options.

  • Red Wine US$9.99

    4 pack

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

P & P New York Style Pizza in Mentor brings the taste of a classic New York pizza joint to the local community. Located at 9853 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Mentor, OH 44060, this pizza restaurant is known for serving traditional NY-style pies with a focus on fresh ingredients, familiar flavors, and satisfying portions.

The menu at P & P New York Style Pizza features whole pizzas and slices, making it easy to enjoy a quick meal or share a full pie with family and friends. The New York-style approach means customers can expect thin, foldable crusts, flavorful toppings, and a balance of cheese and sauce in every bite. Whether you are stopping by for lunch, grabbing dinner after a busy day, or picking up food for a group, the restaurant offers convenient options for every occasion.

In addition to pizza, P & P New York Style Pizza serves a variety of subs and salads. The subs provide a hearty choice for guests looking for something beyond pizza, while fresh salads offer a lighter option to complete a meal. This variety makes the restaurant a comfortable choice for different tastes and cravings.

One of the highlights of this Mentor pizza spot is the ability to order pizza by the slice. This makes it a great option for anyone who wants a classic New York slice without ordering a whole pie. At the same time, larger pizza orders are available for gatherings, celebrations, or casual nights at home.

The restaurant’s welcoming style reflects the charm of a neighborhood pizza shop. Guests can enjoy familiar comfort food in a relaxed setting, with menu choices that focus on quality and convenience. The combination of traditional pizza-making style, generous portions, and a diverse menu helps P & P New York Style Pizza stand out among local dining options.

For pizza lovers in Mentor, P & P New York Style Pizza offers a dependable place to enjoy classic flavors. From crispy slices and full-size pies to satisfying subs and fresh salads, the restaurant provides simple, delicious meals made for everyday dining.

Other menus in Mentor

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Mentor listings
Menu Directions